Sunday, December 25, 2005
Portfolio Analysis from Fidelity
Fidelity did an analysis of my portfolio and in their analysis they considered the historical results of several different model portfolios from 1926 to 2005. Below is some of the information but I cannot figure out how to put it in a table. For 30 years and 15 years all portfolios are in positive territory and the more aggressive the portfolio the wider the range of results from best to worst. At 15 years a conservative portfolio varies from 11.44% best to 2.9% worst whereas an aggressive growth portfolio varies from 18.2% best to .91% worst. As the time gets shorter the best to worst variation gets more extreme for the aggressive portfolios. Note that the difference in average return for the balanced, growth and aggressive growth portfolios only differ by 1.7%. A balanced portfolio has 40% bonds and 10% short term and yet it's average return was 8.22%. If we had a way to guarantee 8% returns, we'd jump on it. Note that with the current portfolio there has been a year where that portfolio lost 52%. Even for a balanced portfolio there was a year where the portfolio lost 40%. What would I do if my portfolio lost 40%?
If I wanted to move my current portfolio toward a balanced portfolio I'd have to move some stock/mutual fund investments to bonds either in the IRA or in the taxable account. In the taxable account the only investment which makes any sense is Municipal bonds/funds. In the IRA taxable bonds/funds makes some sense. As I cash more stock options I can put the money in bond tax free funds to move toward balanced.
Portfolio conservative/balanced/growth/Aggressive growth
Time frame 10+/20+/30+/30+
Return
Average 6.19/8.22/9.26/9.97
Best 30 9.42/11.66/12.9/13.8
Worst 30 3.67 5.84 6.84 7.44
Best 15 11.44 14.72 16.72 18.22
Worst 15 2.9 2.75 1.83 .91
Best 5 16.79 22.06 27.23 31.91
Worst 5 -.37 -6.18 -10.43 -13.78
Best 1 31.06 76.57 109.55 136.07
Worst 1 -17.67 -40.64 -52.92 -60.78
Domestic stocks 20 45 60 70
Foreign stocks 0 5 10 15
Bonds 50 40 25 15
Short term 30 10 5 0
If I wanted to move my current portfolio toward a balanced portfolio I'd have to move some stock/mutual fund investments to bonds either in the IRA or in the taxable account. In the taxable account the only investment which makes any sense is Municipal bonds/funds. In the IRA taxable bonds/funds makes some sense. As I cash more stock options I can put the money in bond tax free funds to move toward balanced.
Portfolio conservative/balanced/growth/Aggressive growth
Time frame 10+/20+/30+/30+
Return
Average 6.19/8.22/9.26/9.97
Best 30 9.42/11.66/12.9/13.8
Worst 30 3.67 5.84 6.84 7.44
Best 15 11.44 14.72 16.72 18.22
Worst 15 2.9 2.75 1.83 .91
Best 5 16.79 22.06 27.23 31.91
Worst 5 -.37 -6.18 -10.43 -13.78
Best 1 31.06 76.57 109.55 136.07
Worst 1 -17.67 -40.64 -52.92 -60.78
Domestic stocks 20 45 60 70
Foreign stocks 0 5 10 15
Bonds 50 40 25 15
Short term 30 10 5 0